| Name | Sport | All-Ohio Year |
| Andra Lehotay | Track | 2013–6th 800m Div II
2014–4th 1600m Div II 2015–State Champion 800m Div II 2016–2nd 1600m Div II 2016–4th 800m Div II |
| Luke Kail | Baseball | 2016 |
| Andra Lehotay | Cross Country | 2015–12th Div II |
| Jake Wagner | Football | 2016 |
| Chloe Otte | Softball | 2015 |
| Luke Sommer | Track | 2014–5th Highjump
2015–7th Highjump |
| Joe Newman | Wrestling | 8th Div III 120lb weightclass |
| Sam Groff | Wrestling | 2012–3rd 182lb weightclass
2013–State Runner-up 182lb weightclass |
| Ben Lehotay | Cross Country | 2012–15th |
| Briana Schubert | Track | 2012–6th Long Jump |
| Andrew Milhoan | Track | 2011–8th 110 Hurdles
2012–Long Jump Champion 2012–5th 110 Hurdles |
| Cory Sickafoose | Track | 2010–8th Div II Pole Vault
2011–5th Div II Pole Vault |
| Kelli Mohr | Softball | 2011 |
| Parker Cole | Wrestling | 2011–7th Div III 189lb weightclass |
| Julia Cain | Track | 2008–4th Div II Pole Vault
2009–8th Div II Pole Vault 2010–8th Div II Pole Vault |
| Danielle Grooms | Softball | 2010 |
| Jeff Brothers | Baseball | 2008
2009 |
| Shaynna Johnson | Softball | 2009 |
| Samantha Paul | Softball | 2008 |
| Morgan Cook | Softball | 2006 |
| Mike Coates | Track | Div II 2003–5th |
| Lance Navarra | Wrestling | 2004–2nd Div II 130lb weightclass |
| Caity Schneider | Track | 2003–7th 1600m |
| Erin Lincoln | Softball | 2003 |
| Nicole Lancaster | Softball | 2001 2002 |
| Dwayne Dauski | Wrestling | 2001–2nd Div II 152lb weightclass |
| Caity Schneider | Cross Country | 2000–12th 2001–5th |
| Sean Cilona | Track | 2000–7th Div II PoleVault |
| Shaun Fidder | Track | 1997–5th PoleVault |
| Kris Trent | Wrestling | 1996–5th 275lb weightclass |
| Doug Duff | Wrestling | 1996– 3rd 189lb weightclass |
| Joe Crallie | Track | 1993–2nd Div II LongJump
1994&’95 LongJump Champ 1995 2nd Div II 100 m 4th 200m |
| Jason Calkins | Track | 1994–4th Div II HighJump
1995–Champion Div II HighJump |
| Matt Renecker | Track | 1995–6th 1600m |
| Joe Cobbs | Cross Country | 1993–11th, 1994–9th |
| Ryan Moyer | Wrestling | 1994–5th 171lb Weightclass |
| Matt Renecker | Cross Country | 1993–10th |
| Jason Crallie | Track | 1992–3rd 100m |
| Nick Bosh | Football | 1991 |
| Jeff Boals | Basketball | 1990 |
| Gary Bourquin | Football | 1989 |
| Joe Waller | Baseball | 1985 |
| Jeff McCauley | Track | 1983–3rd PoleVault
1984–2nd PoleVault |
| Beth Manson | Track | 1984–3rd Shotput–5th Discuss |
| Randy Currilla | Football | 1981 |
| Barry Oswald | Baseball | 1980 |
| Steve Miller | Track | 1978–2nd PoleVault
1979–5th PoleVault |
| Bill Murray | Baseball | 1979 |
| Randy Burkus | Baseball | 1978 |
| Ron Myers | Basketball | 1977 |
| Malia May | Gymnastics | 1975 |
| Mike Spadafora | Baseball | 1974 |
| Jodi May | Gymnastics | 1973 |
| Dan Oswald | Baseball | 1968 |
| Marc Inboden | Baseball | 1966 |
